FACT CHECK #S26XWX2H

WHAT WE FOUND

High-credibility academic and government sources explicitly state that reparations have never been paid to the Black descendants of enslaved people in the United States 2. While critics and some political advertisements have argued that welfare benefits and social programs constitute a form of redress 5, experts and researchers reject this framing because those programs are not specifically targeted at Black Americans to address historical harms like slavery or Jim Crow 1 9. Experts such as William Darity and A. Kirsten Mullen note that programs like Medicaid and Social Security are general social safety nets and do not qualify as reparations 9. Furthermore, official federal records, such as House Resolution 414, acknowledge that the United States government has a yet-unmet moral and legal obligation to provide financial reparations to eliminate the racial wealth gap 4. While specific settlements have been paid for isolated incidents—such as the $10 million out-of-court settlement for victims of the Tuskegee syphilis study 6—these are legal redresses for specific medical abuses, not general reparations for systemic racism or slavery 6 12.

SOURCES

1. 1 · hks.harvard.eduACADEMIC
   The United States pays reparations every day—just not to Black America | Harvard Kennedy School

   TIER A

2. 2 · rsfjournal.orgACADEMIC
   Black Reparations in the United States, 2024: An Introduction | RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences

   TIER A

3. 3 · brookings.eduACADEMIC
   Why we need reparations for Black Americans | Brookings

   TIER A

4. 4 · congress.govACADEMIC
   Text - H.Res.414 - 118th Congress (2023-2024): Recognizing that the United States has a moral and legal obligation to provide reparations for the enslavement of Africans and its lasting harm on the lives of millions of Black people in the United States. | Congress.gov | Library of Congress

   TIER A

5. 5 · slaveryandjusticereport.brown.e…ACADEMIC
   Reparations | Brown’s Slavery & Justice Report, Digital 2nd Edition | Brown University

   TIER A

6. 6 · guides.library.umass.eduACADEMIC
   Home - Reparations in the United States - LibGuides at University of Massachusetts Amherst

   TIER A

7. 7 · nysba.orgACADEMIC
   The United States Has Paid Reparations for a Host of Issues. Why not Slavery? - New York State Bar Association

   TIER A

8. 8 · en.wikipedia.orgACADEMIC
   Reparations for slavery in the United States - Wikipedia

   TIER A

9. 9 · abcnews.comACADEMIC
   What America owes: How reparations would look and who would pay - ABC News

   TIER A

10. 10 · freopp.orgACADEMIC
    Instead of Reparations, Expand Opportunities for African Americans - FREOPP

    TIER A

11. 11 · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govACADEMIC
    A plan for black American reparations - PMC - NIH

    TIER A

12. 12 · news.illinois.eduACADEMIC
    Why is the reparations movement gaining momentum in the U.S.? – News Bureau

    TIER A