MEBRO

DISINFO DESK

Science & Health

No, a New Vaccine Study Doesn't Prove Pfizer 'Killed More Americans Than Two World Wars' — It Never Compared the Vaccinated to the Unvaccinated

A newly published Florida registry study found higher 12-month mortality among Pfizer recipients than Moderna recipients. Viral posts are turning that head-to-head comparison into a national death toll the study was never designed to measure.

MISLEADING ≈

FILED NOV 11, 2026 · UPDATED NOV 11, 2026 · 6 SOURCES

The Claim

A study co-authored by Florida Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo and MIT professor Retsef Levi is spreading fast with a simple, explosive message: Pfizer's COVID-19 shot is deadlier than Moderna's, and the toll is staggering. The People's Voice ran the claim as a headline on November 8, 2026 — Pfizer's shots are responsible for "more American deaths than World War I and World War II combined" [2]. Natural News covered the same paper the day before under the header "Study reveals higher mortality risk for Pfizer COVID vaccine recipients" [3], and Ladapo himself is quoted telling followers the results strongly imply "thousands of Floridians died as a result of receiving Pfizer instead of Moderna" [3].

The underlying paper is real. It's a long-circulating analysis — first posted to medRxiv as a preprint in April 2025 [1] and picked up again this month after reportedly appearing in the journal Global Epidemiology [3] — comparing death rates between Florida adults who got Pfizer's BNT162b2 and those who got Moderna's mRNA-1273. What it is not is a study of vaccinated people versus unvaccinated people, which is the comparison the viral framing implies.

The Study, Not the Headline

Even the outlets promoting the paper can't agree on basic facts about it. LifeSiteNews describes a cohort of 1,470,100 Florida adults who got a first Pfizer or Moderna dose between December 2020 and August 2021, matched and followed for 12 months [1]. Natural News instead puts the total at 1,962,822, with roughly a million people matched into each arm on age, sex, race, vaccination month and census tract [3]. The People's Voice lands on a third figure — 981,411 in each group [2]. The study everyone is citing doesn't even have a stable headline number.

The reported mortality gap also shifts depending on who's summarizing it. LifeSiteNews cites a 37% higher all-cause death rate for Pfizer recipients (847.2 vs. 617.9 deaths per 100,000), a 53% higher cardiovascular death rate and an 88% higher COVID-19 death rate [1]. Natural News reports 784 all-cause deaths in the Pfizer group against 562 in the Moderna group — a 39% relative difference — plus a 55% cardiovascular gap and a 90% COVID-19 gap [3]. The People's Voice reports 40%, 57% and 91% for the same three categories [2]. Heartland Institute's health-policy outlet, writing back in June 2025 when the paper was still a preprint, instead framed the gap as "230 more deaths per 100,000" and couldn't decide if the effect showed up in 100 days or 12 months — its own lede and body contradict each other [4].

Natural News's own numbers don't hold up on inspection: 784 versus 562 deaths across roughly a million people per arm is a gap of about 22 extra deaths per 100,000 — not the 221-per-100,000 figure the same article cites a paragraph later [3]. Nobody covering this study, including the outlets hyping it hardest, has managed to report consistent arithmetic.

What It Can't Show

Every version of this story shares the same structural gap: there is no unvaccinated comparison group. The study measures Pfizer recipients against Moderna recipients — not against people who received no vaccine at all [1][3][4]. That makes it impossible to say from this data whether either vaccine raised mortality versus not vaccinating, which is the question the viral "Pfizer killed more people than two world wars" framing actually needs answered.

Even sources sympathetic to the study's conclusions include experts flagging this. Dr. Jane Orient of the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons told Natural News, "What we really need to know is how those vaccinated compare with a matched unvaccinated population" [3]. Merrill Matthews of the Institute for Policy Innovation told Heartland's outlet that "the number of deaths potentially attributable to the vaccines is actually quite low" [4]. Neither quote made it into the headlines built on the same reporting.

The People's Voice's own national death-toll numbers — 522,000 and 331,500 — are explicitly hypothetical arithmetic, not findings from the paper: they take the observed Pfizer-vs-Moderna gap and apply it to an assumed 150 million U.S. Pfizer recipients, treating every death in that hypothetical population as if the relative-risk gap applied uniformly [2]. A back-of-envelope calculation stapled onto a Pfizer-vs-Moderna comparison is not a measured national death count.

A Familiar Pattern

This isn't the first Ladapo-linked vaccine-mortality analysis to draw this kind of overreach. In October 2022, Florida's Department of Health released a different, non-peer-reviewed analysis claiming an 84% higher cardiac-death risk for men 18–39 after mRNA vaccination — produced by anonymous authors, using a design critics said was ill-suited to the question [5][6]. PolitiFact reported that scientists flagged the small sample (about 20 deaths total), over-broad cardiac ICD-10 codes that included conditions with no plausible vaccine link, and the absence of any benefit-risk comparison [5]. FDA official Peter Marks said the findings didn't justify Ladapo's recommendation [5].

Dr. David Gorski of Science-Based Medicine went further, writing that the state's methodology amounted to "antivaccine disinformation disguised as an epidemiological study" and noting the paper's own text admitted it "cannot determine the causative nature of a participant's death" [6]. Ladapo dismissed the peer-review concern at the time as a "fake issue" [5]. The pattern repeats now: a real, limited dataset, a causal conclusion the data can't support, and viral amplification that strips out every caveat along the way.

The Verdict

MISLEADING. The core data point — a measured mortality gap between Florida adults who got Pfizer versus Moderna — appears to be a real, published finding, though outlets covering it can't agree on the cohort size or the exact percentages [1][2][3][4]. What's circulating virally is a causal leap the study's own design cannot support: it never compared vaccinated people to unvaccinated people, so it cannot show the vaccines caused excess deaths at all, let alone a toll exceeding two world wars [1][2][3][4]. That specific comparison is an extrapolation invented by social-media commentary, not a result reported in the paper [2]. Absence of an unvaccinated baseline means the national death-toll claim is unverified, not confirmed — and the study's loudest promoters are the same voices whose past Florida vaccine analyses were already found to overstate their own data [5][6].

MEBRO · DISINFO DESK · mebro.app

Investigative report — not a user-submitted fact-check.

AI-built, source-verified. Every claim here was checked against the sources cited above before publishing — but don't just trust us: follow any citation to its source and confirm it yourself. That's the whole point.